Mailbag: Should I Withdraw from an Old Annuity?

Today’s Prep:

When is a good time to withdraw from an annuity and what should you know ahead of time? Eric answers this and two other questions from the mailbag in this week’s podcast.

Equipping Points:

What kind of financial questions have come up as we continue to live through a pandemic? Eric answers three questions related to student loans, annuities, and being furloughed during this time. Find out what he has to say to these listener questions!

Jan in Osceola has had an annuity for several years and can now withdraw the money without a penalty. Should she take the money out? Eric says this depends. How will the money be used? Will you be transferring it to another annuity or to an IRA? Be sure to consider the taxes you’ll be expected to pay, depending on what you do.

Todd in Van Meter has $16,000 remaining on a student loan for his daughter. He has the money to pay if off, but the interest and the payments are suspended right now due to the pandemic. Should he pay it off or wait? Paying it off while clear you of the debt, but what happens if something were to go awry? Is it worth waiting until we get through these unprecedented times?

Clark in Des Moines was furloughed for about four months this year and received unemployment during those months. But he didn’t have taxes withheld from that, so should he be prepared to pay taxes on that later? Eric explains what the state of Iowa and IRS will consider taxable. Should Clark be concerned about possible penalties? Talking to a tax professional right now may help to offset the taxes in a current paycheck.

Listen to the entire episode or click on the timestamps below to skip to a particular question.

0:50 – Mailbag: Should I withdraw from an old annuity?

4:02 – Mailbag: Should I pay off a student loan that has no interest or payments due?   

6:04 – Mailbag: What will be taxable after being furloughed and on unemployment?

Today’s Takeaway:

Right now, having some cash is nice. Keep that powder drive so that you can handle it if something deals a change your way.

-Eric Peterson

Related Resources:

Is This Retirement Fact or Fiction?

Making The Right Decisions With Your 401(k)

Mailbag: When Should I Take Social Security?

More From Eric:

The host: Eric Peterson - Contact - Call: (515) 226-1500

Subscribe To The Podcast:

Apple Podcasts  -  Google Podcasts  -  Spotify  -  Stitcher  -  iHeartRadio  -  TuneIn

Check out some other recent episodes

The National Park Guide to Retirement Planning

July 16, 2026

Whether you’re visiting one of the 63 national parks this summer or just hitting a local trail, a lot of the best practices for a great hike apply just as well to your retirement plan. Today, Eric “walks” through a few.

Mailbag: Military Pension Mistakes & Retirement Decision Paralysis

July 9, 2026

What happens if you make a retirement decision you can’t undo? And how do you know when you’ve done enough research before making an important financial move? In this mailbag episode, Eric answers two listener questions—one from a military retiree looking to protect his spouse after declining a survivor pension benefit, and another from a listener who struggles with overthinking every financial decision.

Movie Quotes That Reveal the Truth About Retirement

July 2, 2026

Can classic movie quotes actually teach valuable retirement lessons? In this episode, Eric takes memorable lines from films like The Terminator, When Harry Met Sally, and The Wizard of Oz and uses them to explain key retirement-planning concepts. From preparing for inevitable market downturns to understanding why every retirement plan should be personalized, these famous quotes provide surprisingly practical financial insights.

Where Does Guaranteed Income in Retirement Really Come From?

June 18, 2026

What does “guaranteed income” really mean in retirement, and is it actually possible to create a paycheck you can count on for life? In this episode, Eric breaks down the different sources of retirement income, including Social Security, pensions, investments, rental properties, and insurance-based solutions. He explains the risks many retirees overlook when relying solely on portfolios, dividends, bonds, or rental income and discusses why predictable income streams can play an important role in a well-designed retirement strategy.

Mailbag: IRA Withdrawals, Whole Life Insurance & Cash on the Sidelines

June 11, 2026

In this mailbag episode, Eric tackles a variety of listener questions about retirement and financial planning.
He breaks down complex topics into clear, practical guidance to help you make more confident money decisions.

Retirement Lessons Hidden in Walt Disney Quotes

June 4, 2026

Sometimes the best financial lessons come from the most unexpected places. Walt Disney built one of the most recognizable brands in history, but some of his most memorable quotes offer lessons that extend far beyond theme parks and animated characters.

Mailbag: Working Forever, Safety Nets, and Target Date Funds

May 28, 2026

A lot of people think they’ll work forever, until life changes the plan. In this special mailbag episode, Eric answers listener questions about retirement timing, backup planning, target date funds, and how to think about risk as retirement gets closer.

The Financial Impact of Losing a Spouse

May 21, 2026

Losing a spouse is one of the hardest realities anyone can face, and it can create major financial changes that you may not see coming. In this episode, Eric walks through the potential financial impact of becoming suddenly single in retirement, including Social Security changes, tax surprises, IRA rules, beneficiary updates, and income planning challenges.

Leave a Comment